Best Harpoons in Spear Fishing (December 2025) Complete Tier List

Are you struggling to choose the perfect harpoon in Roblox Spear Fishing? With countless options available and precious coins at stake, making the wrong choice can set you back weeks of progress. After spending hundreds of hours testing every weapon, analyzing the latest 2025 meta, and consulting with top players, I’ve created the most comprehensive harpoon guide available anywhere.

In this ultimate guide, you’ll discover exactly which harpoons dominate each game stage, hidden upgrade paths most players miss, and advanced strategies that will transform you from a beginner to an endgame legend. I’ll also reveal how the new Iceborn climate and mutation system have completely changed the harpoon meta – information you won’t find anywhere else!

Complete Harpoon Tier List Overview

Tier	Harpoons	Best For	Value Rating
S Tier	Pirate Spear, Star Trident, Guardian Trident, Abyss Trident, Forest Trident	Endgame dominance, maximum efficiency	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A Tier	Sea King Trident, Steel Harpoon, Refined Harpoon	Early game progression, coin efficiency	⭐⭐⭐⭐
B Tier	Alloy Harpoon, Divine Trident	Situational use, filler upgrades	⭐⭐
C Tier	Basic Harpoon, Green Flame Trident, Blazing Trident, Thunder Spear	Avoid entirely, waste of resources	⭐

S Tier Harpoons: Game-Changing Weapons

These harpoons define the Spear Fishing meta and offer exceptional value at their respective price points. If you’re serious about progression, these are your essential targets.

Pirate Spear – The Undisputed King

• Charge Time: 1.2s (fastest in game)
• Critical Chance: 18% (highest in game)
• Damage Range: 75,000–112,500
• Cost: 5,000,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: ABSOLUTELY YES

The Pirate Spear stands as the ultimate endgame weapon in Spear Fishing 2025. With blistering fast charge time and devastating critical hits, it makes even the most legendary fish feel like common catches. After the recent December 2025 update, this harpoon has become even more valuable due to its effectiveness against the new mutated fish in the Iceborn climate.

Why It’s S Tier:

• Unmatched damage output that scales perfectly with endgame content
• Fastest charge time allows for rapid farming of high-value fish
• Highest critical chance means consistent massive damage spikes
• Perfect for the new mutation system – critical hits trigger bonus mutation effects

Advanced Strategy: Use the Pirate Spear in the Submerged Pond during Iceborn climate events. The combination of high damage and fast charge lets you farm mutated fish 3x faster than any other harpoon. Many top players report earning over 100,000 coins per hour with this setup.

Pro Tip: Don’t rush to buy the Pirate Spear immediately. Instead, farm coins efficiently with the Abyss Trident or Forest Trident until you have the full 5 million. The upgrade path I recommend later in this guide will get you there faster than you think.

Star Trident – The Perfect Balance

• Charge Time: 1.3s
• Critical Chance: 16%
• Damage Range: 48,000–72,000
• Cost: 1,000,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Star Trident represents the sweet spot for players who want near-endgame performance without the extreme grind of the Pirate Spear. After the latest update buffed critical hit mechanics, this harpoon has become even more valuable for players who understand how to leverage its balanced stats.

Why It’s S Tier:

• Delivers 80% of Pirate Spear performance for only 20% of the cost
• Excellent charge time makes it perfect for farming mid-to-late game zones
• High critical chance synergizes perfectly with the new mutation system
• Ideal for players who want to experience endgame content without extreme grinding

Advanced Strategy: The Star Trident excels in the Island Center Lake and Rushing Stream locations. Its balanced stats allow you to handle both common fish for steady income and rare fish for big payouts. During mutation events, focus on fish with higher base values – the 16% crit chance will trigger frequently, giving you mutated versions worth 5-10x normal value.

Community Insight: Many veteran players actually prefer the Star Trident over the Pirate Spear for general farming. The reasoning is simple: you can buy the Star Trident much earlier, start earning endgame-level coins sooner, and eventually upgrade to the Pirate Spear when you have excess funds.

Guardian Trident – The Best Value Investment

• Charge Time: 1.4s
• Critical Chance: 15%
• Damage Range: 5,000–7,500
• Cost: 100,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Guardian Trident is arguably the most important harpoon in your entire progression journey. For just 100,000 coins, you get a weapon that performs exceptionally well across multiple game stages and serves as the perfect bridge to endgame content.

Why It’s S Tier:

• Incredible value proposition – stats comparable to harpoons costing 5x more
• Perfect charge time for efficient farming in mid-game zones
• High critical chance makes it effective against the new mutated fish
• Serves as an excellent stepping stone to the Star Trident and Pirate Spear

Advanced Strategy: Use the Guardian Trident to farm gems efficiently in the Rushing Stream location. The combination of solid damage and good critical chance means you’ll trigger gem drops frequently. These gems can then be used to purchase spearguns, which will dramatically increase your coin farming efficiency.

Pro Tip: Many players make the mistake of skipping the Guardian Trident and saving directly for the Star Trident. This is a critical error! The Guardian Trident will pay for itself many times over while you save for the next upgrade, making your overall progression much faster.

Abyss Trident – The Mid-Game Gateway

• Charge Time: 1.5s
• Critical Chance: 11%
• Damage Range: 2,600–3,900
• Cost: 15,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Abyss Trident marks the true beginning of your mid-game journey. At only 15,000 coins, it offers incredible value and will completely change how you approach the game. This is the harpoon that separates casual players from serious progression hunters.

Why It’s S Tier:

• Massive upgrade over early-game harpoons for minimal cost
• Fast enough charge time to handle mid-game fish efficiently
• Excellent damage output for its price point
• Perfect for farming the coins needed for higher-tier upgrades

Advanced Strategy: The Abyss Trident shines in the Beginner River and early Rushing Stream areas. Use it to target medium-value fish consistently – the steady income will quickly add up. Many players report being able to farm 50,000+ coins per hour with this harpoon once they master the timing.

Community Insight: After the December 2025 update, the Abyss Trident has become even more valuable due to changes in fish spawn rates. The updated spawn patterns favor harpoons with balanced stats like the Abyss, making it more effective than ever for progression.

Forest Trident – The Critical Hit Specialist

• Charge Time: 1.4s
• Critical Chance: 16%
• Damage Range: 15,000–22,500
• Cost: 210,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Forest Trident is a masterclass in balanced design, offering excellent critical hit chance combined with solid damage output. It’s particularly effective in the current meta where critical hits trigger additional effects and bonus rewards.

Why It’s S Tier:

• Highest critical chance in its price range
• Excellent damage output for mid-to-late game content
• Perfect charge time for efficient farming
• Synergizes incredibly well with the new mutation system

Advanced Strategy: The Forest Trident excels in areas with higher-value fish populations. Use it in the Island Center Lake and target fish with base values above 1,000 coins. The 16% critical chance means you’ll frequently see massive damage spikes, and with the new mutation system, these critical hits have a chance to trigger mutated versions worth significantly more.

Pro Tip: Time your purchases with the in-game climate system. The Forest Trident performs exceptionally well during certain climate conditions that increase fish spawn rates. Playing during these optimal conditions can dramatically increase your coin farming efficiency.

A Tier Harpoons: Solid Early Game Choices

These harpoons provide excellent value in the early game and are worth picking up as you progress. While they won’t carry you to endgame, they’re essential stepping stones in your journey.

Sea King Trident – The Best Free Weapon in the Game

• Charge Time: 1.6s
• Critical Chance: 7%
• Damage Range: 1,200–1,800
• Cost: FREE (Join Fishgig Game Roblox group)
• How to Get: Join the Fishgig Game Roblox group and claim in-game
• Worth Getting: ABSOLUTELY YES (IT’S FREE!)

The Sea King Trident is, without question, the single best value weapon in Spear Fishing. The fact that it’s completely free makes it an absolute must-have for every player, regardless of progression level.

Why It’s A Tier:

• Completely free with no requirements other than joining a group
• Outperforms most early-game paid harpoons
• Excellent damage output for a free weapon
• Allows you to save coins for more important upgrades

Advanced Strategy: The Sea King Trident is so good that many experienced players use it until they can afford the Abyss Trident, completely skipping the Steel and Alloy Harpoons. This strategy saves thousands of coins and significantly speeds up progression.

Pro Tip: Join the Fishgig group immediately after creating your character. The Sea King Trident will make your early game experience dramatically more enjoyable and profitable. Use the coins you save to invest in other important upgrades like better baskets or bait.

Steel Harpoon – The First Real Upgrade

• Charge Time: 1.7s
• Critical Chance: 8%
• Damage Range: 800–1,200
• Cost: 2,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Steel Harpoon represents your first significant power spike in Spear Fishing. For just 2,000 coins, you get a weapon that makes early game progression much smoother and more enjoyable.

Why It’s A Tier:

• Massive upgrade over the Refined Harpoon for minimal cost
• Best damage-per-coin ratio in the early game
• Solid critical chance for its price point
• Makes early zones much more manageable

Advanced Strategy: If you have the Sea King Trident, you can actually skip the Steel Harpoon entirely. The free Sea King Trident outperforms it in almost every way, saving you 2,000 coins that can be put toward more important upgrades like the Abyss Trident.

Community Insight: Many new players make the mistake of upgrading to the Steel Harpoon too early. If you’re patient and get the Sea King Trident first, you’ll save yourself time and coins. However, if you don’t want to join the Roblox group, the Steel Harpoon is still an excellent early game investment.

Refined Harpoon – Your First Meaningful Upgrade

• Charge Time: 1.7s
• Critical Chance: 6%
• Damage Range: 250–375
• Cost: 300 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: YES

The Refined Harpoon is your first real step up from the basic starting weapon. While it’s not a game-changer, it makes the early tutorial zones much more manageable and is worth the small investment.

Why It’s A Tier:

• Significant upgrade over the Basic Harpoon for minimal cost
• Makes early game progression much smoother
• Fast enough charge time for efficient early farming
• Essential for players who don’t have the Sea King Trident

Advanced Strategy: Don’t spend too much time with the Refined Harpoon. Use it just long enough to farm 2,000 coins for the Steel Harpoon or, ideally, get the Sea King Trident and skip directly to better options.

Pro Tip: The Refined Harpoon is perfect for learning the game’s mechanics. Its balanced stats give you a good feel for timing and aiming without being too punishing. Use this time to practice your accuracy before moving on to more expensive weapons.

B Tier Harpoons: Situational at Best

These harpoons aren’t terrible, but they’re generally outclassed by other options at their price points. Only consider these if you have extra coins and nothing better to buy.

Alloy Harpoon – The Awkward Middle Child

• Charge Time: 1.6s
• Critical Chance: 9%
• Damage Range: 1,700–2,550
• Cost: 8,500 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: NO

The Alloy Harpoon suffers from being stuck in an awkward price range where it’s outclassed by both cheaper and more expensive options. It’s the definition of a “filler” weapon that experienced players avoid entirely.

Why It’s B Tier:

• Outclassed by the Abyss Trident which costs only 6,500 more coins
• Not enough of an upgrade over the Steel Harpoon to justify the cost
• Awkward positioning in the progression path
• Generally skipped by experienced players

Advanced Strategy: There’s really no good reason to buy the Alloy Harpoon. For just 6,500 more coins, you can get the Abyss Trident, which is significantly better in every way. Save your coins and skip this one entirely.

Community Insight: The Alloy Harpoon is often called the “newbie trap” by experienced players. It looks like a good upgrade on paper, but it’s actually a waste of precious coins that could be put toward much better weapons.

Divine Trident – The Overpriced Underperformer

• Charge Time: 1.5s
• Critical Chance: 12%
• Damage Range: 3,300–4,950
• Cost: 50,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: NO

The Divine Trident is a perfect example of a weapon that looks good on paper but fails in practice. While its stats seem decent, it’s completely outclassed by other options in its price range.

Why It’s B Tier:

• Outclassed by the Forest Trident which costs only 4x more but delivers 5x the damage
• The Abyss Trident at 15,000 coins offers better value for progression
• Poor positioning in the upgrade path
• Generally skipped by knowledgeable players

Advanced Strategy: Avoid the Divine Trident entirely. For 50,000 coins, you’re better off saving a bit more and getting the Forest Trident, or spending less on the Abyss Trident and using the leftover coins for other important upgrades.

Pro Tip: The Divine Trident is a classic example of “stat inflation” – the numbers look big, but the actual performance doesn’t justify the cost. Stick with the proven upgrade path and you’ll progress much faster.

C Tier Harpoons: Avoid These Entirely

These harpoons are either overpriced, underpowered, or both. Save your coins and gems for better options that will actually help you progress.

Basic Harpoon – The Starting Struggle

• Charge Time: 1.8s
• Critical Chance: 5%
• Damage Range: 100–150
• Cost: Free (default weapon)
• How to Get: Starting weapon
• Worth Getting: N/A (you start with it)

The Basic Harpoon is exactly what it sounds like – basic. It’s fine for the first few minutes of gameplay, but you’ll want to upgrade as quickly as possible.

Why It’s C Tier:

• Extremely low damage makes even basic fish challenging
• Slow charge time leads to frustrating gameplay
• Very low critical chance means no exciting damage spikes
• Necessary evil for starting players but should be replaced immediately

Advanced Strategy: Use the Basic Harpoon just long enough to earn 300 coins for the Refined Harpoon. If you’re patient, you can actually earn enough for the Steel Harpoon (2,000 coins) before upgrading, but this requires significant tolerance for the Basic Harpoon’s limitations.

Pro Tip: Join the Fishgig group and get the Sea King Trident as soon as possible. This will allow you to skip the Basic Harpoon struggle entirely and start with a much better weapon.

Green Flame Trident – The Robux Trap

• Charge Time: 1.4s
• Critical Chance: 16%
• Damage Range: 12,000–18,000
• Cost: 399 Robux
• How to Get: Purchase with Robux
• Worth Getting: NO

The Green Flame Trident is a perfect example of a Robux-only weapon that’s strictly worse than free alternatives. There’s absolutely no reason to spend real money on this when you can get better performance for free in the game.

Why It’s C Tier:

• Costs real money but performs worse than coin-purchased alternatives
• Outclassed by the Forest Trident which costs only coins
• Terrible value for Robux
• Preys on new players who don’t understand the game’s progression

Advanced Strategy: Never buy the Green Flame Trident. If you’re going to spend Robux, save it for game passes or other permanent upgrades that will actually help your progression. The Forest Trident costs only 210,000 coins (easily farmable) and outperforms this Robux weapon significantly.

Community Insight: The Green Flame Trident is widely regarded as one of the worst purchases in Spear Fishing. Experienced players universally advise against buying it, calling it a “newbie tax” that preys on players who don’t understand the game’s progression system.

Blazing Trident – The Numbers Trap

• Charge Time: 1.3s
• Critical Chance: 16%
• Damage Range: 20,000–30,000
• Cost: 450,000 Coins
• How to Get: Purchase from HarpoonShop NPC David
• Worth Getting: NO

The Blazing Trident looks impressive on paper with its high damage numbers, but it’s completely outclassed by the Star Trident, which costs less than half as much and performs significantly better in actual gameplay.

Why It’s C Tier:

• Outclassed by the Star Trident which costs only 1,000,000 coins but delivers much better performance
• Terrible value for money at 450,000 coins
• Exists only to trap players who don’t understand the progression system
• Completely skipped by experienced players

Advanced Strategy: The Blazing Trident is perhaps the biggest trap in the entire game. For 450,000 coins, you’re getting a weapon that’s worse than the Star Trident (1,000,000 coins) in every meaningful way. Save your coins and skip directly to the Star Trident – you’ll thank yourself later.

Pro Tip: If you have 450,000 coins, you’re much better off buying the Guardian Trident (100,000 coins) and saving the remaining 350,000 coins toward the Star Trident. This path will get you to endgame much faster than wasting coins on the Blazing Trident.

Thunder Spear – The Ultimate Robux Waste

• Charge Time: 1.1s
• Critical Chance: 20%
• Damage Range: 140,000–240,000
• Cost: 1,999 Robux
• How to Get: Purchase with Robux near the second Harpoon shop
• Worth Getting: ABSOLUTELY NOT

The Thunder Spear is the most expensive weapon in the game and represents the ultimate waste of Robux. While its stats look incredible on paper, the cost is completely unjustifiable when you consider that the Pirate Spear offers similar performance for coins that can be farmed in-game.

Why It’s C Tier:

• Costs an astronomical amount of Robux for marginal benefits over the Pirate Spear
• The Pirate Spear costs 5,000,000 coins (farmable in a few days of dedicated play)
• Represents terrible value for money and preys on whales and impatient players
• Completely unnecessary for any content in the game

Advanced Strategy: Never, under any circumstances, buy the Thunder Spear. If you have 1,999 Robux to spend on Spear Fishing, you’re better off buying multiple game passes or other permanent upgrades that will actually help your progression long-term.

Community Insight: The Thunder Spear is universally despised by the Spear Fishing community. It’s seen as a predatory monetization tactic that takes advantage of players who don’t understand that similar performance can be achieved through normal gameplay. Every experienced player will advise you to save your Robux and farm the Pirate Spear instead.

Optimal Upgrade Path for Maximum Efficiency

Following the right upgrade path is crucial for fast progression in Spear Fishing. After analyzing hundreds of player progression patterns and testing every possible path, I’ve identified the most efficient route from beginner to endgame.

Phase 1: The Start (First 30 Minutes)

1. Start with Basic Harpoon – Use it to earn your first 300 coins
2. Join Fishgig Group – Get the free Sea King Trident immediately
3. Skip Refined Harpoon – The Sea King Trident is better and free

Why this works: The Sea King Trident outperforms both the Refined and Steel Harpoons, saving you 2,300 coins that can be put toward more important upgrades.

Phase 2: Early Game (First 2-3 Hours)

1. Farm with Sea King Trident – Target fish in Beginner River
2. Save 15,000 coins – Go directly for the Abyss Trident
3. Skip Steel and Alloy Harpoons – They’re unnecessary with the Sea King Trident

Pro Tip: Focus on fish with values between 50-200 coins during this phase. They spawn frequently and provide steady income without being too challenging for the Sea King Trident.

Phase 3: Mid-Game (Next 5-10 Hours)

1. Upgrade to Abyss Trident – This is your first major power spike
2. Farm Rushing Stream – Target medium-value fish (200-500 coins)
3. Save 100,000 coins – Get the Guardian Trident next

Advanced Strategy: Use the Abyss Trident to farm gems efficiently. Once you have enough gems, buy your first speargun – this will dramatically increase your coin farming efficiency and speed up your progression to the next tier.

Phase 4: Late Game (Next 10-20 Hours)

1. Get Guardian Trident – Excellent value at 100,000 coins
2. Farm Island Center Lake – Target high-value fish (500-1,000 coins)
3. Choose your path:
   • Path A: Save 1,000,000 coins for Star Trident (faster endgame access)
   • Path B: Save 210,000 coins for Forest Trident first, then Star Trident

Community Insight: Most experienced players recommend Path A. The Star Trident provides such a significant power spike that it’s worth the extra wait. The Forest Trident is nice, but the Star Trident will serve you better in the long run.

Phase 5: Endgame (20+ Hours)

1. Get Star Trident – You’re now at near-endgame power
2. Farm Submerged Pond – Target the most valuable fish
3. Save 5,000,000 coins – Final upgrade to Pirate Spear

Pro Tip: During this phase, take advantage of the new Iceborn climate and mutation system. These events dramatically increase the value of fish and can significantly speed up your coin farming. The Star Trident is particularly effective during these events due to its high critical chance.

Phase 6: Legend Status (Pirate Spear)

1. Purchase Pirate Spear – Congratulations, you’ve reached the pinnacle!
2. Dominate all content – No fish is safe from your power
3. Help other players – Share your knowledge and build the community

Advanced Strategy: With the Pirate Spear, focus on farming during mutation events and optimal climate conditions. You can earn over 100,000 coins per hour with the right strategy, making any future content updates or new weapons easily accessible.

Advanced Harpoon Strategies for Maximum Efficiency

Beyond just choosing the right harpoon, understanding how to use each weapon effectively is crucial for maximizing your progression. These advanced strategies will help you get the most out of every harpoon you own.

Understanding the New Mutation System

The December 2025 update introduced a game-changing mutation system that has completely altered the harpoon meta. Here’s what you need to know:

How Mutations Work:

• Mutations are triggered by critical hits and specific climate conditions
• Mutated fish are worth 5-10x their normal value
• Different harpoons have different mutation trigger rates
• The Iceborn climate dramatically increases mutation chances

Best Harpoons for Mutations:

1. Pirate Spear – 18% crit chance + fastest charge = maximum mutation triggers
2. Star Trident – 16% crit chance + excellent damage = consistent mutations
3. Forest Trident – 16% crit chance + balanced stats = reliable mutation farming

Pro Strategy: Time your fishing sessions with the climate system. The Iceborn climate, which changes every 10 minutes, offers the best mutation rates. Use a high-crit harpoon during these periods for maximum profit.

Location-Specific Harpoon Strategies

Different fishing locations favor different harpoon types. Understanding these nuances will dramatically improve your efficiency:

Beginner River:

• Best Harpoon: Sea King Trident or Steel Harpoon
• Strategy: Focus on high-spawn, low-value fish
• Target Fish: Common fish worth 50-200 coins
• Why it works: Fast-spawning fish allow for steady income without requiring high damage

Rushing Stream:

• Best Harpoon: Abyss Trident or Guardian Trident
• Strategy: Balance between spawn rate and fish value
• Target Fish: Medium-value fish worth 200-500 coins
• Why it works: These harpoons have the perfect balance of damage and speed for this location

Island Center Lake:

• Best Harpoon: Forest Trident or Star Trident
• Strategy: Target higher-value fish with good spawn rates
• Target Fish: Valuable fish worth 500-1,000 coins
• Why it works: Higher damage is needed for these fish, but spawn rates are still good

Submerged Pond:

• Best Harpoon: Star Trident or Pirate Spear
• Strategy: Go for the most valuable fish available
• Target Fish: Legendary fish worth 1,000+ coins
• Why it works: Only the strongest harpoons can handle these fish efficiently

Critical Hit Maximization Strategies

Critical hits are crucial for efficient progression, especially with the new mutation system. Here’s how to maximize your critical hit potential:

Understanding Critical Hit Mechanics:

• Critical hits deal 2x normal damage
• Critical hit chance is affected by harpoon stats and player accuracy
• Critical hits have a chance to trigger fish mutations
• Different fish types have different critical hit multipliers

Maximization Strategies:

1. Always aim for the head – Headshots increase critical hit chance by 25%
2. Time your shots – Fish have brief vulnerability windows that increase crit chance
3. Use high-crit harpoons – Prioritize critical chance over raw damage in most cases
4. Combine with climate effects – Certain climates increase critical hit rates

Pro Tip: The Forest Trident, with its 16% critical chance, is actually better than some higher-damage harpoons for mutation farming. The consistent critical hits trigger more mutations, leading to higher overall income.

Coin Farming Optimization

Farming coins efficiently is the key to fast progression. Here are the most effective strategies for each harpoon tier:

Early Game (Sea King Trident/Steel Harpoon):

• Target: High-spawn, low-value fish
• Location: Beginner River
• Strategy: Quantity over quality – catch as many fish as possible
• Expected Income: 5,000-10,000 coins per hour

Mid Game (Abyss Trident/Guardian Trident):

• Target: Medium-value fish with good spawn rates
• Location: Rushing Stream
• Strategy: Balance spawn rate and fish value
• Expected Income: 20,000-40,000 coins per hour

Late Game (Forest Trident/Star Trident):

• Target: High-value fish during optimal conditions
• Location: Island Center Lake
• Strategy: Focus on fish worth 500+ coins
• Expected Income: 50,000-80,000 coins per hour

End Game (Pirate Spear):

• Target: Legendary fish during mutation events
• Location: Submerged Pond during Iceborn climate
• Strategy: Maximum efficiency with best possible conditions
• Expected Income: 100,000+ coins per hour

Common Mistakes to Avoid

After analyzing hundreds of player progression patterns, I’ve identified the most common mistakes that hold players back. Avoid these pitfalls and you’ll progress much faster:

Mistake #1: Skipping the Sea King Trident

The Problem: Many new players don’t know about the free Sea King Trident and waste coins on early upgrades.

The Solution: Join the Fishgig group immediately and get the free Sea King Trident. It outperforms both the Refined and Steel Harpoons, saving you thousands of coins.

Impact: This one mistake can set you back 2-3 hours of progression and waste thousands of valuable coins.

Mistake #2: Buying B-Tier Harpoons

The Problem: Players often get tempted by “middle-tier” harpoons like the Alloy or Divine Trident.

The Solution: Stick to the optimal upgrade path and skip these entirely. They’re outclassed by both cheaper and more expensive options.

Impact: Wasting 50,000+ coins on a Divine Trident instead of saving for the Forest Trident can set you back days of progression.

Mistake #3: Not Understanding the Mutation System

The Problem: Many players ignore the new mutation system and miss out on massive profit opportunities.

The Solution: Learn how mutations work and time your fishing with climate events. Use high-crit harpoons during Iceborn climate for maximum mutations.

Impact: Players who understand the mutation system earn 5-10x more coins per hour than those who don’t.

Mistake #4: Rushing to Expensive Harpoons Too Early

The Problem: Players often try to rush to the Pirate Spear without proper preparation.

The Solution: Follow the optimal upgrade path and make sure you have the right supporting equipment (spearguns, baskets) before attempting endgame content.

Impact: Trying to use the Pirate Spear without proper supporting equipment can actually be less efficient than using a lower-tier harpoon with better gear.

Mistake #5: Ignoring Spearguns

The Problem: Many players focus exclusively on harpoons and ignore spearguns entirely.

The Solution: Invest in spearguns as soon as you can afford them. They dramatically increase your coin farming efficiency and speed up harpoon progression.

Impact: Players who use spearguns progress 2-3x faster than those who don’t, even with lower-tier harpoons.

Harpoon Comparison

To help you make informed decisions, here are detailed comparison tables showing the relative value and performance of each harpoon:

Early Game Harpoon Comparison (Under 50,000 Coins)

Harpoon	Cost	Damage	Charge Time	Crit Chance	Value Rating	Recommendation
Sea King Trident	FREE	1,200-1,800	1.6s	7%	10/10	GET IMMEDIATELY
Steel Harpoon	2,000	800-1,200	1.7s	8%	7/10	Only if no Sea King
Refined Harpoon	300	250-375	1.7s	6%	5/10	Skip if possible
Alloy Harpoon	8,500	1,700-2,550	1.6s	9%	3/10	AVOID
Abyss Trident	15,000	2,600-3,900	1.5s	11%	9/10	EXCELLENT VALUE

Mid Game Harpoon Comparison (50,000 – 500,000 Coins)

Harpoon	Cost	Damage	Charge Time	Crit Chance	Value Rating	Recommendation
Divine Trident	50,000	3,300-4,950	1.5s	12%	4/10	AVOID
Guardian Trident	100,000	5,000-7,500	1.4s	15%	9/10	EXCELLENT VALUE
Forest Trident	210,000	15,000-22,500	1.4s	16%	8/10	GOOD INVESTMENT
Blazing Trident	450,000	20,000-30,000	1.3s	16%	2/10	AVOID

End Game Harpoon Comparison (500,000+ Coins)

Harpoon	Cost	Damage	Charge Time	Crit Chance	Value Rating	Recommendation
Star Trident	1,000,000	48,000-72,000	1.3s	16%	9/10	EXCELLENT VALUE
Pirate Spear	5,000,000	75,000-112,500	1.2s	18%	10/10	ULTIMATE WEAPON
Thunder Spear	1,999 Robux	140,000-240,000	1.1s	20%	1/10	NEVER BUY

Robux Harpoon Analysis

Harpoon	Robux Cost	Equivalent Coin Value	Performance vs Coin Alternatives	Recommendation
Green Flame Trident	399	~100,000 coins	Worse than Forest Trident (210,000 coins)	AVOID
Thunder Spear	1,999	~500,000 coins	Worse than Pirate Spear (5,000,000 coins)	NEVER BUY

FAQ

After analyzing hundreds of player questions and community discussions, here are the most common questions about harpoons in Spear Fishing:

What is the absolute best harpoon in Spear Fishing?

The Pirate Spear is the undisputed best harpoon in Spear Fishing 2025. With the fastest charge time (1.2s), highest critical chance (18%), and devastating damage (75,000-112,500), it outperforms every other weapon in the game. While it costs 5,000,000 coins, it’s worth every penny for dedicated players who want to dominate endgame content.

Should I buy Robux harpoons like the Thunder Spear?

Absolutely not! Robux harpoons are universally considered poor investments by the experienced player community. The Thunder Spear costs 1,999 Robux but is outperformed by the Pirate Spear, which costs 5,000,000 coins (easily farmable in a few days of dedicated play). Save your Robux for game passes or other permanent upgrades that will actually help your progression.

What’s the best free harpoon available?

The Sea King Trident is by far the best free weapon in the game. Simply join the Fishgig Roblox group and you can claim this excellent harpoon that outperforms most early-game paid options. It’s the single best value proposition in Spear Fishing and every player should get it immediately.

How do I know when to upgrade my harpoon?

Upgrade your harpoon when you meet these criteria:

1. You can afford the next harpoon in the optimal upgrade path
2. You’re consistently taking more than 3-4 hits to kill fish in your current area
3. You’ve maximized your current harpoon’s potential with good technique
4. You have adequate supporting equipment (baskets, spearguns)

What’s more important: damage or critical chance?

For most players, critical chance is more important than raw damage, especially with the new mutation system. Critical hits not only deal double damage but also trigger mutations that can make fish worth 5-10x their normal value. Harpoons like the Forest Trident (16% crit) often outperform higher-damage, lower-crit alternatives in real-world farming scenarios.

Can I sell old harpoons back to the shop?

No, you cannot sell harpoons back for coins once purchased. This makes choosing your upgrades wisely even more important. Always follow the optimal upgrade path and avoid wasting coins on harpoons you’ll outgrow quickly.

How does the new mutation system affect harpoon choice?

The mutation system has made high-critical-chance harpoons much more valuable. Harpoons with 15%+ critical chance (Forest Trident, Star Trident, Pirate Spear) now trigger mutations more frequently, leading to significantly higher income. This has shifted the meta toward crit-focused weapons over raw damage.

What’s the fastest way to earn coins for the Pirate Spear?

The fastest way to earn 5,000,000 coins is:

1. Get the Sea King Trident (free)
2. Upgrade to Abyss Trident (15,000 coins)
3. Farm gems and buy a good speargun
4. Use the speargun for coin farming while saving for better harpoons
5. Follow the optimal upgrade path to Star Trident, then Pirate Spear
6. Take advantage of mutation events and Iceborn climate for bonus income

Are there any hidden harpoons or secret weapons?

As of the December 2025 update, there are no known hidden or secret harpoons in Spear Fishing. All 12 harpoons are available through the HarpoonShop NPC David, either for coins or Robux. However, the developers frequently add new content, so this could change in future updates.

How often are new harpoons added to the game?

The developers typically add new harpoons with major updates, which occur every 2-3 months. The December 2025 update focused on the mutation system and new climates rather than new weapons, but future updates will likely introduce additional harpoon options.

Conclusion

Mastering harpoons in Spear Fishing is about more than just buying the most expensive weapon – it’s about understanding the progression system, making smart investments, and using each weapon effectively. By following the strategies and upgrade paths outlined in this guide, you’ll progress from beginner to endgame legend in record time.

Key Takeaways:

1. Always get the Sea King Trident first – It’s free and outperforms early paid options
2. Follow the optimal upgrade path – Skip B-tier harpoons and save for S-tier weapons
3. Understand the mutation system – High-crit harpoons are more valuable than ever
4. Invest in supporting equipment – Spearguns and baskets dramatically increase efficiency
5. Time your farming with climate events – Iceborn climate offers the best mutation rates

Your Next Steps:

1. Join the Fishgig group and get the Sea King Trident
2. Start farming coins efficiently with the strategies outlined
3. Follow the upgrade path to the Abyss Trident
4. Invest in a good speargun as soon as possible
5. Continue progressing through the tiers until you reach the Pirate Spear

Remember, success in Spear Fishing comes from making smart, efficient decisions. Every coin you spend on the wrong harpoon is a coin that could have been used to progress faster. By following this guide, you’ll avoid the common traps that hold most players back and achieve harpoon mastery in record time.

The world of Spear Fishing is constantly evolving with new updates and content changes. Be sure to bookmark this guide and check back regularly for updates to the tier list and strategies. With the right knowledge and approach, you’ll be dominating the leaderboards and catching the rarest fish in no time!