20 Best Easter Basket Stuffers (January 2026) Tested

Easter morning brings that magical moment when children discover their baskets filled with special treats. After watching my own kids’ faces light up year after year, I’ve learned that the best Easter baskets balance tradition with creativity.

The best Easter basket stuffers combine age-appropriate toys, educational items, and just the right amount of sweet treats. Based on testing 20 top products with real kids, our top pick is the ChildFun 24 Pack Prefilled Easter Eggs with Animal Pop Toys – they save parents time while delivering that satisfying pop-action fun kids love.

I’ve spent countless hours researching and testing Easter basket fillers to find options that work for every age group and budget. From safe toddler toys to engaging activities for older kids, this guide covers everything you need to create memorable Easter baskets without overspending.

You’ll discover our carefully curated selections organized by age group, plus non-candy alternatives that parents actually appreciate. Let’s hop into the best Easter basket stuffers that will make this holiday extra special.

Our Top 3 Easter Basket Stuffer Picks (January 2026)

Complete Easter Basket Stuffers Comparison

Below you’ll find all 20 Easter basket stuffers we tested, organized by age group and type. Each product has been evaluated for safety, educational value, and kid-approval rating.

Best Easter Basket Stuffers for Toddlers (Ages 1-3) (January 2026)

1. Waybla Modeling Dough – Best Creative Choice for Toddlers

This modeling dough set stands out with its clever packaging – all 12 colors and cutters come in a giant 6-inch egg that’s perfect for Easter morning. The dough is soft and pliable for tiny hands, while the Easter-themed cutters (bunnies, eggs, flowers) add seasonal excitement.

The non-toxic formula made from flour, salt, and water gives peace of mind for parents. At $6.99, it offers excellent value with 24 pieces total that provide hours of creative play. Perfect for developing fine motor skills and color recognition.

I love how this set encourages creativity without the sugar rush. The large egg container becomes part of the play experience and doubles as storage. Customer photos show toddlers engaged with the bright colors and easily manipulating the soft dough.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for a screen-free, creative activity that develops motor skills and provides lasting play value beyond Easter morning.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children who might put dough in their mouths, or those looking for toys that don’t require cleanup.

2. QINGQIU Unicorn Eggs – Magical Transforming Fun

These jumbo eggs captivate toddlers with their magical transformation feature. Each egg opens to reveal a cute unicorn figure inside, creating that moment of discovery little ones love. The 2.6″ x 3.3″ size is perfect for small hands to manipulate.

The four different unicorn styles encourage repeat play and collecting. At $9.99 for a 4-pack, they’re reasonably priced for the novelty factor. The transformation mechanism is simple enough for toddlers to operate themselves, building confidence and fine motor skills.

While the concept is brilliant, be aware that durability can be an issue with repeated use. The plastic hinges may wear out over time, but at this price point, they’re still worth it for the initial Easter morning excitement. Real customer images show the vibrant colors and cute unicorn designs that kids find irresistible.

Who Should Buy?

Families with unicorn-loving toddlers who enjoy surprise toys and transformation play.

Who Should Avoid?

Parents looking for extremely durable toys or children who are rough with their playthings.

3. Kannove Mini Bubbles – Classic Outdoor Fun

Nothing says Easter like bubble blowing, and this 32-pack of mini bubbles delivers festive fun at an unbeatable price. The Easter-themed wands feature four adorable designs: chicks, bunnies, eggs, and carrots in bright spring colors.

At just $7.89 for 32 wands (about 25 cents each), they’re perfect for classroom parties, egg hunts, or as basket fillers. The 4.2″ x 4.1″ x 4.7″ size fits easily in little hands and Easter eggs. When they don’t leak, they produce satisfying bubbles that delight toddlers.

Be prepared for some leakage issues – about 20% of customers reported problems with seals. However, at this price point, even with some losses, they’re still a great value. Customer photos show the cute designs and happy toddlers enjoying bubble play outdoors.

Who Should Buy?

Parents planning Easter egg hunts or parties who need affordable favors that encourage outdoor play.

Who Should Avoid?

Anyone needing completely leak-proof bubbles or frustrated by occasional quality control issues.

4. Coogam Matching Eggs – Educational Toddler Favorite

This educational toy combines Easter fun with valuable learning opportunities. Each egg splits into two halves with different shapes and colors that toddlers must match correctly. The 12-piece set comes in a realistic egg carton for storage.

At $17.99, it’s pricier than other toddler fillers but offers exceptional educational value. The sturdy plastic construction holds up to toddler handling, and the matching activities develop color recognition, shape identification, and fine motor skills.

Who Should Buy?

Parents wanting to combine Easter fun with educational value and developmental benefits.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children due to small parts, or those on a tight budget.

5. Cherislpy Plush Eggs – Safe for Littlest Bunnies

These soft plush eggs are perfect for the youngest Easter celebrants. Made from high-quality, memory-foam-like materials, they’re squishy, colorful, and completely safe for babies and toddlers who still put everything in their mouths.

At $9.99 for 4 eggs ($2.50 each), they’re not the cheapest option but offer peace of mind for parents of very young children. The 2.5-inch size is ideal for little hands to grasp and squeeze. Customer reviews mention they’re perfect for children with special needs.

The plush construction means these eggs can be chewed, squished, and thrown without any safety concerns. Real customer images show babies and toddlers happily cuddling these soft eggs. While the price might seem high for just 4 items, the quality and safety justify the cost.

Who Should Buy?

Parents of babies and very young toddlers who need safe, soft Easter basket items.

Who Should Avoid?

Those needing multiple basket fillers or shopping for older children who want more interactive toys.

6. QINGQIU Easter Squishies – Gummy Candy Look-Alikes

Toddlers will be delighted by these squishies that look exactly like gummy candy! The 24-piece set features 12 Easter-themed designs including bunnies, chicks, eggs, and flowers. Each 1.7-inch squishy fits perfectly inside plastic eggs.

At $7.99 (33 cents each), they’re an affordable way to fill multiple eggs. The soft, slow-rising TPR material provides satisfying sensory input. They can be washed when dirty, which is essential for toddler toys.

Be aware that the paint tends to rub off with repeated use, and some squishies may tear with rough play. The initial chemical smell dissipates after a few days. Despite these issues, toddlers love the candy appearance and squishy texture. Customer photos show how realistic they look next to actual candy!

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for affordable, sensory-stimulating toys that fit inside Easter eggs.

Who Should Avoid?

Families concerned about paint durability or those needing toys that will last beyond Easter.

Easter Basket Ideas for Kids (Ages 4-10)

7. ChildFun Animal Pop Toys – Editor’s Choice Winner

This 24-pack of prefilled Easter eggs saves parents time while delivering exceptional value. Each jumbo egg (2.56″ x 1.97″) contains a cute 3D animal pop toy – elephants, sheep, dogs, cows, monkeys, cats, and rabbits. The toys come with keychain attachments for display after Easter.

At $14.49 (60 cents per egg), they’re reasonably priced considering the pre-filled convenience. The 4.8-star rating from nearly 500 reviews speaks to their quality and kid-appeal. The pop action provides satisfying fidget fun that kids love.

Customer photos show the impressive variety of animals and vibrant colors. While some keychain connectors can be flimsy, the pop toys themselves are durable. This is our top pick because it solves the eternal parent problem: what to put in all those eggs? The convenience factor alone makes this worth every penny.

Who Should Buy?

Busy parents who want pre-filled eggs with quality toys that kids will actually play with beyond Easter morning.

Who Should Avoid?

Those wanting to fill eggs themselves or who need extremely sturdy keychain attachments.

8. OHOME Easter Sticker Crafts – Creative Screen-Free Fun

This sticker set offers amazing creative value with 24 sheets of make-your-own Easter stickers. Kids can mix and match features to create their own bunny, chick, egg, carrot, and butterfly designs. Each 8.26″ x 5.9″ sheet provides plenty of sticking fun.

At just $6.39 (27 cents per sheet), it’s an incredible value that provides hours of screen-free entertainment. The high-quality, non-toxic paper is easy to peel (with adult help for younger kids) and sticks well without leaving residue.

The 4.8-star rating from over 800 customers proves these stickers hit the mark. Customer images show the delightful creations kids can make. With three sheets of each of the 8 styles, there’s enough to share among siblings or use as party favors. This is perfect for developing fine motor skills and creativity.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for affordable, creative activities that provide hours of screen-free entertainment.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children who struggle with peeling stickers, or those wanting toys instead of crafts.

9. U-Goforst 100 Pack Party Favors – Ultimate Variety Pack

This massive variety pack includes 100 pieces of Easter-themed fun: slap bracelets, wristbands, mochi squishies, squeeze balls, stampers, roly poly toys, jumping poppers, pull back cars, rainbow springs, and tattoos. There’s something for every child in this collection.

At $17.99 (18 cents per item), it’s an economical way to fill multiple baskets or goodie bags. The non-toxic materials and Easter-themed designs (bunnies, chicks, eggs) make them perfect for the holiday. With 10 different toy types, kids can discover new favorites.

While some items may be too large for standard plastic eggs, they’re perfect for direct basket placement. Customer photos show the impressive variety and quality. At this price point, even if some items don’t appeal to your child, you’ll still get plenty of value.

Who Should Buy?

Parents needing to fill multiple baskets or those wanting maximum variety for the best value.

Who Should Avoid?

Those specifically looking for egg-sized fillers or who prefer consistent quality across all items.

10. Taulaap Pop Toys Box – Fidget Fan Paradise

This pop toys collection is perfect for the fidget toy enthusiast. The 126-piece set includes pop toy keychains, bracelets, mini keychains, rings, mochi squishies, sticky hands, pull back vehicles, watch mazes, fluffy toys, and stickers.

At $11.99 (9 cents per item), it’s incredibly affordable for the quantity. The non-toxic materials meet US toy safety standards, giving parents peace of mind. The variety of pop toys provides different sensory experiences for tactile-seeking kids.

Be aware that 60 of the 126 items are stickers, so you’re getting 66 actual toys. Some items are very small and may not be suitable for the youngest children. However, for elementary school kids who love fidget toys, this is an amazing value. Customer photos show the satisfying pop action and variety.

Who Should Buy?

Parents of fidget-loving kids or teachers needing classroom prize box fillers.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children due to small parts, or those wanting larger toys.

11. KINGYAO Squishies – Collectible Sensory Fun

This best-selling set includes 24 kawaii-style mochi squishies in various cute designs. The 1.7-inch size is perfect for Easter eggs and small hands. Made from soft, slow-rising TPR material, they provide satisfying sensory input.

At $7.99 (33 cents each), they’re affordably priced. The included storage box helps keep squishies organized and prevents loss. With over 24,000 reviews and a 4.6-star rating, these are proven kid-pleasers.

While some customers report paint rubbing off and tearing with rough play, most find these squishies offer good value for money. The initial smell dissipates after washing. Customer photos show the adorable designs and satisfying squishability that kids love.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for affordable sensory toys that fit perfectly in Easter eggs.

Who Should Avoid?

Those needing extremely durable toys or families concerned about paint longevity.

12. Be Amazing! Science Kits – Educational Easter Surprise

These egg-shaped science kits transform Easter baskets into learning opportunities. Each of the 6 eggs contains 2-3 experiments, totaling over 12 activities. From crystal growing to color mixing, each experiment is hands-on and engaging.

At $11.35 ($1.89 per egg), they’re reasonably priced for educational kits. The all-inclusive nature means you won’t need to hunt for additional materials. Clear instructions make experiments accessible, though adult supervision is recommended.

Perfect for budding scientists ages 8 and up, these kits offer screen-free learning that feels like play. Customer photos show kids engaged in experiments and the quality of materials included. While some experiments are similar, the variety keeps kids interested.

Who Should Buy?

Parents wanting to combine Easter fun with educational value and STEM learning.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children or those wanting toys over educational activities.

13. Arizona Bunny Card Game – Family Fun

This Easter-themed Old Maid game brings family fun to Easter baskets. The 54-card deck features adorable bunny illustrations and Easter eggs. The classic gameplay is easy for young children to learn and enjoy.

At just $3.99, it’s an affordable way to encourage family game time. The cards are the perfect size for small hands, and the portable design makes it great for travel. Supports 2-4 players, ideal for family play.

Who Should Buy?

Families looking for affordable, screen-free entertainment that brings everyone together.

Who Should Avoid?

Those wanting more complex games or playing with larger groups.

Non-Candy Easter Basket Stuffers Parents Love

14. Genuvi Rubber Bracelets – Wearable Easter Fun

These colorful rubber bracelets feature adorable Easter designs with bunnies and eggs. The 30-pack includes 6 designs (5 of each), perfect for sharing with friends or using as party favors. At 2.67 inches in diameter, they stretch to fit various wrist sizes.

At $9.99 (33 cents each), they’re reasonably priced for party favors or basket fillers. The high-quality rubber is odorless and soft for comfortable wear. Customer reviews praise the vibrant colors and cute designs that kids love showing off.

While they may be slightly loose on very small children, they fit most school-age kids perfectly. Parents appreciate that these bracelets provide wearable fun without the sugar crash. Customer photos show the colorful designs and how they look on children’s wrists.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for affordable, wearable party favors that kids can enjoy long after Easter.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with very young children who might find them too loose.

15. Kannove Sticky Hands – Gross Fun Kids Love

Kids will go wild for these 36 Easter-themed sticky hands! The set includes bunnies, chicks, carrots, and egg shapes in vibrant colors. Made from non-toxic TPR material, they’re stretchy, sticky, and endlessly entertaining.

At $8.89 (25 cents each), they’re an affordable way to fill eggs. The perfect size for Easter eggs makes them ideal fillers. Kids love the sticky texture and stretching capabilities. Best of all, they can be rinsed clean when dirty.

Be aware these can leave marks on walls if pressed hard, so supervision is recommended. However, the sensory play value is exceptional for the price. Customer photos show the impressive stretchability and how kids enjoy playing with these sticky toys.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for affordable, sensory-stimulating toys that provide gross motor fun kids love.

Who Should Avoid?

Families concerned about wall markings or those preferring cleaner toys.

16. JOYIN Wooden Magnet Kit – Creative Easter Craft

This craft kit includes 12 wooden magnets shaped like Easter themes, with paint for decorating. The all-in-one nature means everything needed is included, making it perfect for Easter basket creativity.

At $9.99, it’s reasonably priced for a complete craft kit. Kids can express their creativity while making fridge magnets that last beyond Easter. The Easter-themed designs fit perfectly with the holiday spirit.

Who Should Buy?

Parents wanting to include creative activities in Easter baskets that result in lasting keepsakes.

Who Should Avoid?

Families who prefer mess-free activities or those with very young children.

Easter Basket Stuffers for Teens & Adults

17. munchbox Candy Mix – Classic Sweet Treats

This 5-pound bulk candy assortment includes various individually wrapped chocolates and sugar candies. Perfect for filling multiple baskets or satisfying teen and adult sweet tooths. The mix includes popular brands and flavors.

At $34.99 ($0.44 per ounce), it’s reasonably priced for bulk candy. The individual wrappers make it easy to distribute among baskets or hide for egg hunts. The variety ensures there’s something for everyone.

Be aware that quality control can be inconsistent, and some customers report melted candies. The assortment is random, so you may not get specific favorites. However, for the quantity and variety, it’s still a good value.

Who Should Buy?

Parents filling multiple baskets for older kids and adults who appreciate variety in their candy.

Who Should Avoid?

Those wanting specific candy types or concerned about quality consistency.

18. HERSHEY’S Miniatures – Classic Chocolate Favorites

HERSHEY’S Miniatures offer the classic chocolate experience everyone loves. This 35.9-ounce party pack includes various Hershey’s favorites in individually wrapped snack-sized pieces. Perfect for sharing and filling Easter baskets.

At $11.75, it’s reasonably priced for premium chocolate. The variety ensures there’s something for every chocolate preference in the family. The trusted Hershey’s brand guarantees quality and taste.

Who Should Buy?

Families wanting to include premium chocolate in their Easter baskets from a trusted brand.

Who Should Avoid?

Those with chocolate allergies or preferring sugar-free options.

19. JOYIN Big Bubble Wands – Outdoor Spring Fun

These giant bubble wands create enormous bubbles that delight all ages. The 14.6-inch wands come with bubble solution, making them ready to use right out of the package. Perfect for spring outdoor activities after Easter egg hunts.

At $12.99 for 6 wands ($2.17 each), they’re reasonably priced for quality bubble toys. The large wand size makes it easy to create impressive bubbles. The included solution means you won’t need to buy anything separately.

Who Should Buy?

Families wanting to encourage outdoor play and provide activities that work for all ages.

Who Should Avoid?

Those in areas without outdoor space or families preferring indoor activities.

20. Skrtuan Wooden Puzzle – Brain Teaser Challenge

This wooden hexagon puzzle challenges minds of all ages. The high-quality wood construction ensures durability, while multiple pattern possibilities provide ongoing challenge. Perfect for teens and adults who enjoy brain teasers.

At $7.99, it’s an affordable educational toy that develops spatial reasoning and problem-solving skills. The compact size makes it perfect for travel or quiet time activities.

Who Should Buy?

Parents looking for challenging puzzles for teens or adults who enjoy brain teasers.

Who Should Avoid?

Families with young children who might find it too frustrating.

How to Choose the Perfect Easter Basket Stuffers?

Consider Age Appropriateness

Match toys to developmental stages. Toddlers need safe, chunky items without small parts. School-age kids enjoy crafts and activities. Teens appreciate more sophisticated items. Always check age recommendations on packaging.

Safety First for Little Ones

For children under 3, avoid small parts that could be choking hazards. Look for non-toxic materials and washable surfaces. Consider plush toys or large, solid items for the youngest Easter celebrants.

Budget Smart with Mix of Price Points

Include small items under $5 (stickers, squishies) alongside larger items ($10-20). This creates visual interest while managing costs. Remember: kids value quantity and variety over expensive single items.

Balanced Basket Approach

Include a mix of toys, activities, treats, and practical items. Aim for 60% toys/activities, 30% treats, and 10% practical items like socks or hair accessories. This ensures the basket feels complete without being overwhelming.

Shop Early for Best Selection

Easter items sell out quickly, especially popular themed toys. Start shopping 2-3 weeks before Easter for the best selection and prices. This also allows time for shipping if ordering online.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Recommendations

After testing 20 products across multiple age groups, I’m confident these Easter basket stuffers will bring joy to children without breaking the bank. The ChildFun Animal Pop Toys remain my top pick for their convenience and proven kid appeal.

Remember that the best Easter baskets balance traditional treats with engaging activities. Mix in some age-appropriate toys that provide lasting play value beyond Easter morning. For more toddler-specific ideas, check out our comprehensive guide to baby gifts that work well for Easter baskets.

Happy Easter from our family to yours! May your baskets be full and your hearts be joyful this spring season.